Homebuilders Benefit from Tight Existing Home Market: Builder Confidence on the Rise

image source cnbc.com

Homebuilders are experiencing a surge in confidence and activity due to the limited availability of existing homes for sale. The National Association of Home Builders (NAHB)/Wells Fargo Housing Market Index (HMI) reported a 5-point increase in builder confidence for newly built single-family homes in May, marking the fifth consecutive month of gains. This positive trend is driven by homeowners choosing to stay in their current homes rather than sell, resulting in a low supply of existing homes.

The Impact of Limited Existing Home Supply

According to NAHB Chairman Alicia Huey, the scarcity of existing homes is causing an uptick in new home construction. Homeowners with mortgages at rates lower than the current market are opting not to sell, further exacerbating the supply shortage. However, builders still face challenges in meeting the growing demand. While the price of lumber has decreased since March, shortages of building materials persist. Additionally, residential real estate development and construction face tightening credit conditions due to recent banking crises and higher interest rates.

Positive Builder Sentiment and Market Conditions

The NAHB/Wells Fargo HMI reveals improvements in all three components of the index. Current sales conditions increased by 5 points to 56, sales expectations for the next six months rose by 7 points to 57, and buyer traffic climbed 2 points to 33. Builders are benefitting from the lean existing home market, as new listings in April dropped by nearly 22% compared to the previous year. Rising mortgage rates may discourage some potential sellers from moving to higher-rate homes, further reducing inventory. Consequently, new construction remains a significant part of buyers' search efforts.

Incentives and Changing Market Dynamics

To attract buyers, homebuilders have been offering incentives such as reduced mortgage rates. However, these incentives are gradually diminishing as demand continues to rise. The share of builders lowering home prices decreased from 30% in April to 27% in May, reflecting a decreasing trend in recent months. While a majority of builders still provide some form of sales incentive, the percentage has dropped from 62% in December to slightly over 50%.

Regional Trends in Builder Sentiment 

On a three-month moving average, builder sentiment remained unchanged in the Northeast at 45. In the Midwest, sentiment increased by 2 points to 39, while in the South, it rose by 3 points to 52. The West saw a 3-point improvement, reaching 41 in builder sentiment. These regional variations demonstrate the ongoing recovery and resilience of the housing market across different parts of the country.

The shortage of existing homes for sale is driving increased confidence and activity among homebuilders. Despite challenges related to material shortages and tightening credit conditions, the construction of new homes continues to meet the growing demand. As incentives reduce and buyer interest remains strong, homebuilders are poised to play a significant role in meeting the needs of prospective buyers in the coming quarters.